Dividend Confusion

Every now and then i read news about dividend declaration by Mutual Funds and every time i read such news, i am sure a lot of investors especially new to the world of investing in mutual funds are mis-guided. Basically, a mutual fund offers three schemes to choose from : growth, dividend re-investment, and dividend pay-out. These have been in the market for quite some years now but many investors still dont completely understand the last one (dividend payout).

Simply speaking, a dividend payout scheme returns back a portion of an investors own money. Full Stop ! When and How much is upto the descrition of the company (thats why it cannot be a guranteed source of income as otherwise thought and promoted by many). Why does an MF declare a dividend? One reason might be there is no asset worth investing in the market at the moment. e.g. when markets are over-heated. Other reason might also be to attract new investors to the fund luring them to grab this "income".

For e.g. if you have invested $100 in a scheme which declares a 2 $ dividend, then your investment in the scheme now becomes 98$ if you had opted for a dividend pay-out scheme with the 2$ returned to you. Its as simple as that. Its upto you to decide what to do with that 2$. There are also some tax implications with dividends but i will leave them out from this discussion. The point is the term "dividend" seems so attractive that mis-informed investors easily fall prey to all the positive marketing about such schemes. They also plan their investment (in some cases even encouraged by the investment advisors!) close to the schemes dividend declaration date to capture that "dividend" because there is a gap between when the company declares a dividend and the time the money reaches the bank account.

My personal recommendation would be to invest in an MF (scheme suited to your equity-debt exposure) with a good track-record atleast for the past 5 years rather than falling prey to this very "attractive" dividend proposition. Finally, how much net return you make in the long-term is what really matters with or without dividends.

Missed the Bus?Dont miss the Flight

Many individual investors feel that they missed the recent stock market rally. The stock market gave a fantastic over 30% returns in just a couple of months and stocks with high beta (higher volatility to the market) gave more than 50%. Those who invested in stocks then (and very few of them did) enjoyed enormous gains. While those who had put in their money a year ago are still struggling to break-even. But it was not only the retail investors who missed this years spectacular rally.

Almost all Mutual Funds (supposed to be managed by smart money managers) were sitting idle all these months. Mutual Fund data shows that funds were sitting on a cash pile of upto Rs 20,000 crore !!! as of April-end. They were waiting for the market to correct post-election. But just the opposite happened. The election results were un-expectedly positive, the market zoomed and everyone were a mere spectator to the rally. But money managers should have realized that valuations had already hit the bottom. Unsystematic Risk was still there and there was no strong reason enough to be optimistic but it was clear that many stocks were dirt cheap and the path from thereon was north-wards towards their fair price even though at a slow pace. But they totally missed it. What are these funds doing now? They are waiting again as they think valuations are too high now ! to enter so they want to wait before prices correct again. These Investment Mangers advise investors not to time their Investment and have a long-term horizon to achieve decent returns. But what they themselves do is the opposite.

Individual and Institutional Investors may have missed the bus by not getting in the market. I think, if they continue to wait further, they might miss the Flight towards the next rally.

Auto Profit Booking - Mutual Fund

Timing ! and more Correct Timing ! we know in all activities including Investment decisions is so important. Sometime or the other, we have felt "I should have invested in this a year ago and i would have made a killing" or "It was a stupid decision to buy that stock 2 months ago. Rather it would have made more sense to sell it and lock the 10% gain"....Timing our investments is very difficult and even though you have planned when to get in, you have to also carefully plan when to get out.

Recently, i read a news about a new Mutual Fund that gives an option to an investor regarding the exit point. i.e. Auto Redemption of fund units. Investors can choose between 10,20,50,100% return options. With this feature, once the fund returns since invested date reach the desired percentage, the units are auto-redeemed and the proceeds are invested in a safer instrument (such as a debt fund for example).

With this feature, an investor gets his desired returns which are then safeguarded (from value erosion in case of adverse market movement). Plus he doesnt need to track the market to find an exit point. Infact, i feel this feature can also aid to control investor greed. Studies have found that only few people redeem their investment at their desired return level. This is because investors become more greedy after a certain return % is reached and they still want more out of their investment !

I find the auto-redemption feature pretty cool and i wish all AMCs should have this option for all of their Funds especially in these uncertain times. This feature would certainly benefit the common investors. However, ofcourse if the market continues to move southwards, this feature is useless !